Leeds United, Melvin Bard, and the Deadline Day Panic Button

Leeds United and Melvin Bard might not have been two names many of us expected to see together this late in the window, but here we are. The transfer window is drawing to a close, and Leeds have been chasing a left-back all summer. Injury to Joe Rodon during the 1-1 draw with Brentford at the weekend has likely forced our hand.

It would probably be fair to assume Bard wasn’t right at the top of the list when Leeds started looking for another left-back earlier in the summer. But this late in the window, a loan with an option to buy feels like a pretty sensible solution. Bard gives Leeds experienced cover for Gabriel Gudmundsson without committing a significant fee to someone who may ultimately spend much of the season on the bench.

More importantly, it doesn’t tie Leeds’ hands next summer. If Bard comes in and proves he’s good enough to challenge Gudmundsson properly, there’s an option to keep him. If he doesn’t, Leeds can go back into the market next summer and look again for a longer-term first-choice left-back.

As deadline-day deals go, there are certainly worse ways of doing it.

PLAYER PROFILE

Melvin Bard is a 25-year-old French left-back currently playing for OGC Nice. He’s naturally left-footed and, although primarily a full-back, has also played as a wing-back and on the left of a back three under Franck Haise.

Reports in France have now linked Bard with a late move to England, with Leeds among the clubs credited with an interest. Nice have already looked at Eintracht Frankfurt’s Niels Nkounkou as a possible replacement, while Bard is reportedly valued at more than €10 million. However, Leeds look to have struck a loan agreement with Nice which as it turns out is…well…nice.

CAREER CONTEXT

Bard came through Lyon’s academy and made his senior debut in December 2019. His proper breakthrough came the following season, when he made 18 appearances in all competitions, including 14 in Ligue 1. By then he’d also worked his way through the French youth system, representing his country from U18 level through to the U21s.

His time at Lyon was brief, though.

In the summer of 2021, Bard represented France at the Tokyo Olympics before leaving Lyon permanently for Nice at the age of 20. He made his Nice debut against Reims on the opening weekend of the 2021/22 Ligue 1 season and went on to make 37 appearances in all competitions during his first year, scoring twice and adding two assists. And he hasn’t really looked back.

Bard played another 44 games in 2022/23, including ten in Nice’s run to the quarter-finals of the Europa Conference League, before producing arguably his best season in 2023/24. He made 34 appearances, started 32 Ligue 1 games and finished second in Nice’s Player of the Season vote behind Marcin Bułka.

That season was probably important for another reason. Nice brought Romain Perraud in from Southampton to compete with him for the left-back position, but Bard kept his place and ended up playing regularly in a defence that finished the season with the best defensive record in Ligue 1.

2023/24 Ligue 1 – Nice

• 7.26 FotMob rating (39thoverall)
• 1.3 successful dribbles per 90 (66th overall)
• 5.4 defensive contributions per 90 (105th overall)
• 2.3 tackles per 90 (58th overall)
• 6.9 recoveries per 90 (39th overall)

The arrival of Franck Haise then changed his job slightly. Bard has played as a conventional left-back, a wing-back and occasionally on the left of a back three. He made another 32 appearances in 2024/25, scored twice and finished third in Nice’s Player of the Season vote. His ability to fill in at centre-back also became increasingly useful, with L’Équipe noting how regularly Haise had trusted him there.

At this point, we’re not talking about a young player with half a season of senior football behind him. Bard has made 152 Ligue 1 appearances for Nice alone, alongside experience in the Champions League qualifiers, Europa League and Conference League. He also has the versatility required to be able to play/cover multiple positions for Leeds should he be needed.

PHYSICAL PROFILE

At 5’8″, Bard obviously isn’t a particularly big left-back. But that doesn’t necessarily make him weak.

He competes well physically and isn’t particularly easy to knock off the ball. However, his size does inevitably give him more of a problem in the air. He won 53.3% of his aerial battles last season, which isn’t disastrous for someone standing 5’8″, but you’re obviously not buying him to dominate six-foot-plus forwards at the back post.

There is also an interesting bit of context to his physical development. Bard admitted in 2023 that fitness had been one of his biggest problems when he first joined Nice and so he changed his diet, lost four or five kilos and felt the difference himself. I wish I had his dedication!

ATHLETICISM

The reality with Bard is that he isn’t some ridiculously quick full-back who’s going to spend 90 minutes running past people for fun. What he does have is the engine to keep getting up and down the left. As we know with both Bogle and Gudmundsson, playing at wing-back leaves you responsible for a huge amount of ground.

His recovery work is one of the better parts of his game. He reads danger reasonably early, tracks runners and has enough pace to get himself back into defensive positions when Nice lose the ball. Get French Football News analysed parts of his performances and they highlighted how his contribution is mainly felt in his own half as “he is excellent at tracking back, rarely loses a man, is aggressive in the duels, has good anticipation, and is good at playing out under pressure within his own third”. 

It isn’t all sunshine and rainbows however, with the same report claiming that he has failed to raise his game further, with the inference being that the player has plateaued.  

STRENGTHS

• Tackling
• Positioning
• Recovery runs
• Work rate
• Ball carrying
• Versatility

WEAKNESSES

• Aerial ability
• Final ball
• Attacking output
• Mistakes

CURRENT LEVEL

Bard is an established Ligue 1 left-back with more than 150 league appearances for Nice and plenty of European experience. At 25, you’re buying somebody who should be capable of contributing immediately rather than waiting two years to find out what you’ve got.

FLOOR

A dependable Premier League squad player who can cover left-back, wing-back and, if needed, the left side of a three. His experience and defensive game should prevent this being a complete punt.

CEILING

A good Premier League starting left-back. He’s 25 rather than 20, though, so I wouldn’t be expecting some enormous transformation from the player he already is.

MY VERDICT

Injury to Joe Rodon has likely meant that Leeds have had to press the panic button. I don’t believe Bard was ever the first-choice target at left-back. But if the reports in France surrounding the deal are correct, and this is an initial loan with a €1 million fee, then it makes sense. It allows Leeds to reassess next summer and makes sense with where the squad currently is. If Bard impresses, we have a pretty cheap option to fulfil the back up role. If he’s not what’s needed, the recruitment team can once again see if their first choice is available next summer.

For now, Gabi Gudmundsson is the starting left-back. I don’t think Leeds need to spend £20-25 million trying to replace him twelve months after signing him. What we do need is another option.

Bard has played more than 150 Ligue 1 games for Nice. He’s played European football. He’s been a regular in one of the better defences in France, finished second and third in Nice’s Player of the Season voting in consecutive years and has played in three different positions down the left under Haise.

That gives you something fairly safe. And it also means that James Justin isn’t required to cover at RB, CB and LB. So as an experienced, relatively inexpensive second left-back? This will do. For now.

Enjoyed this? After The Bell will always be free. If you'd like to support the site, you can buy me a coffee and cake. It's Farke's favourite. 🤍💙💛